Sri Lanka 1st Test - Report Cards

Some blog posts contain unedited fan-submitted content — Create an account to start your own blog

The first test is done. So we thought we might try our hand at a little report carding.

Paranavitana.

Plucked out of the opener’s carousel and slotted into be Dilshan’s latest partner. Although going by stats Paranavithana and Dilshan form Sri Lanka’s 2nd best opening combination in history. We liked bringing him back. Slow yes but probably a little steadier than Thirimanne. Looked alright against the quicks but played Ajmal like he was trying to swat flies with his eyes closed. It didn’t work nor did it look particularly healthy. As an opener you might think batting against spinners isn’t that important a factor but every great opener has been at least competent at it. At the moment the competent line is a dot in the horizon for Paranavitana. The problem for him will always be that he will never be guaranteed an extended run to gain valuable experience at the openers spot. You can almost be certain that if he fails in this series he will be dropped for the next. It can’t be easy playing with one eye always looking over your shoulder. Confidence must be nurtured for players like Paranavitana who need time in the middle more than anything else.

Dilshan

This is probably the best you will see Dilshan play in this format of the game. Too often he plays as if his brain is in a vegetative state. However for this test, the intelligent, controlled Dilshan turned up. And when he does he bosses attacks around. His aggression was subdued but was always a threat. He was never tied down. The scoreboard kept moving and that helps guys like Sangakkara to come in and play themselves in without any real pressure. The most important factor in Dilshans batting in the first innings was his SR against Ajmal which clocked in at 60. By not allowing the opposition’s main threat to settle into a rhythm he put Sri Lanka in control. Early. He also played perfectly in the 2nd innings when Sri Lanka needed quick runs. This is the Dilshan that Sri Lanka needs to show up to test matches

Sangakkara

We’ve highlighted in the past how Sangakkara has started a dangerous trend in starting a test series poorly over the last year. Barring the Pakistan tour to the UAE, he has had an almost abysmal record in the first few innings of a tour. What that immediately meant was Sri Lanka’s first innings totals suffered. Scores of over 300 have been rare. Under 200 too often. In short, Sangakkara is a huge chunk in Sri Lanka’s batting line up. And that is not a secret. In this test he built and built and built in an almost robotesque manner. The King is a man of process and every little drill he practices at the nets was on display in this marathon innings. Throughout the innings we couldn’t help but feel that this is what remains of Sanga. An unrelenting machine who has had a few oil leaks recently. We doubt we will ever see the free flowing Sangakkara who flayed the Australians in Hobart. The new Sangakkara or rather the last days of Sangakkara will probably be seen in the same light as Tendulkar in the manner they score their runs. There wasn’t anything particularly brilliant about it but rather just the construction of runs. He looked steady against the quicks but didn’t seem completely settled against Ajmal but that is his asset. To score ugly runs. Sangakkara has always been a better player of pace than spin and it will be really interesting to see how he fares if he has to come in early with Ajmal on song and pressure.

Jayawardene

To counter Sangakkaras monotony, Jayawardene brought a lazy elegance to both innings. His strike rate of nearly 90 against Ajmal proves just how good a player of spin he is. He was never hurried or under pressure. But the problem with Mahela has always been that he allows his flair to get the better of him. In both innings he played shots he didn’t need to. The fact that Sri Lanka were so ahead probably allowed to him play this way but Jayawardene should know he is better than to throw it away. In the field he didn’t really need to do much in the first innings as Pakistan imploded on the face of some good bowling. But the decision on the follow on was rather poor. With 372 on the board and Sri Lanka having bowled on 50 over’s spread across two days, there wasn’t a logical reason for opting to bat again. We believe it goes down to the Sri Lankan culture of ensuring that the team do not lose first instead of going all out when they smell a bit of blood. Pakistan had shown no capability to make Sri Lanka bat again and Sri Lankans bowlers were in no real need of a rest either. It’s a negative move that tells us that Sri Lanka are still not ready to trust themselves to be ruthless.

Samaraweera.

Looked uncomfortable against Ajmal and had a very poor test. For all of Thilan’s strengths, high quality spin bowling is probably not one of them. The fact that Ajmal, Singh and Swann feature in the top 5 bowlers who have picked him up confirms this theory. This is a concern considering that at no5 Thilan plays the pivot in which the entire batting line up revolves around. But if anyone can find a way to get to the light at the end of the tunnel it is him. It’s rare for him to have a poor series these days so expect him to come back strong in the next two games

Mathews

Another poor performance in test cricket. In a couple of years time Mathews will probably not be bowling in tests. And the question is whether he is capable of playing as a pure batsman. The answer right now is no. His technique against spin is poor. But his biggest problem right now is that he does not appear to know how to approach a test innings. One thing that you immediately notice when Mathews bats is that he has no shots to get off strike. He either blocks it or tries to go for a bigish shot. He is also very tentative and needs to feel bat on ball hence the reason why you see him getting out searching for the ball or lunging at it. All this adds to Mathews being a little out of depth as a test batsman. He is fine when he needs to chase a target in a limited number of overs. He handles pressure well, we know that. But give the man a chance to build an innings – he crumbles. We once felt it might his maiden hundred hoodoo. That came and went and Sri Lanka is still waiting on the promise of Mathews. Right now he is being played on what he can achieve than what he actually is. But for how long. Chandimal anyone?

P.Jayawardene

PJ came out in the first innings when Sri Lanka looked like they were going to let go of the initiative that Dilshan and Sangakkara had built. But as with most of his innings recently Jaywardene set about in a workman like fashion to put SL back on top. He is also probably Sri Lankas 3rd best player of spin after Dilshan and Mahela. And it showed. He was never really troubled by Ajmal and he handled the quicks equally well. And at the moment, you’d have to think that his batting is far more important to Sri Lanka than Mathews. He was safe with the gloves but still looks to be searching for his best form. A good all round game.

Randiv.

How Randiv is now a test specialist can only be explained by Sri Lankas selectors. We’ve always felt that Randiv is a bowler who will only get better with time and his return of 7 wickets for the game shows that he is slowly maturing and is supporting Herath perfectly. He got bounce and turn but I guess at Galle you always do. At times he was a bit short but in general a good confidence builder heading into the rest of the series. The challenge for him now will be to prove that he can consistently pick up wickets.

Herath

Steady and dependable as ever. His arm bowl appears to be Pakistan’s kryptonite. It has been quite brilliant watching Herath emerge out of the shadow of Murali over the last year and a bit to stand as his own man. He is easily Sri Lankas best bowler and the most consistent. There is a steely fire in the man that you have to appreciate. He has dropped his bowling average by 7 pts over the last year. And it continues to drop. The biggest plus for Herath is that he picking up wickets against pretty much every opposition and everywhere he bowls.

Kulesekara

An inspired selection based on current form. Kulesekara has no real business being in a test side but he bowled quite superbly to dismantle Pakistan. Over the last 6 months his consistency has been brilliant. He has added to his repertoire and proved that on form he can be as good as anyone. Sangakkara is already calling him a spearhead which is probably a little premature given that it’s been one game and against flaky opposition. The question was always going to be whether he could translate his ODI form in to the tests with the red ball. He did that and then some. It will be interesting to see his stats in the rest of the series. Pakistan’s technique outside the off stump was quite poor and will surely be one of the areas that they will look to tighten up on. Challenge accepted Kule ?

Pradeep

Bowled steadily but didn’t hit a consistent enough length to trouble anyone. His pace and movement were encouraging and he ran in all day with the same vigour. All good signs. Hopefully Sri Lanka plays him for the full series now that Welegedara is also out. In fact there is no real need to change the playing XI at all.

Damith Samarakoon blogs regularly at www.theflyslip.net. Listen to his Podcast - The Armchair Critics. Follow him on twitter @theflyslip

Comments

Ravana's picture
Member since:
8 July 2010
Last activity:
16 hours 16 min

Thanks for that analysis. I feel that you are being a bit short with Mathews because he is the most important member of the team of the future. Let him be and gain experience and stature.

Afraid we can't have the same luxury with Nuwan Pradeep. How can we let him gain experience in the test team ? He has to play his cricket elswhere and gain much needed skills and match practice.

Jeewan Mendis has to play! With so many right handers in the Pakistan team and the fact that he is the only spinner who is getting appreciable turn, on current form.

In my view a slight change in the team is needed and it can be :

(1) Nuwan Pradeep out, Mathews opens the bowling and Jeevan comes in.

(2) Nuwan Pradeep replaced by Thisara Perera who bowls as well and bats and field much better.

(3) Most radical of all Samaraweera rested and Jeevan comes in.

Damith Samarakoon's picture
Member since:
26 December 2008
Last activity:
11 weeks 5 days

I dont disagree that Mathews has to play on. But for how long is the question. He is quite clearly one of THE most important players in the SL set up, specially with the captaincy issue. But there will have to come a time when SL need to value his worth in the test side. Obviously not in the immediate future but Mathews has to transform himself as a test batmen in the next year or so. Otherwise SL will need to carry him. So far he is clearly a hit or miss player.

With Wele out, Eranga out, and Lakmal and Prasad dropped (but think that was for the first test only), Pradeep to me seems like a good choice. The issue is whether playing in FC cricket in SL will help him. The standard there isnt good enough for anyone to really develop the way we'd want them to. Perhaps a county stint or some games in Aus/ SA or touring with SL A is a good way to go. HE bowled OK in the first test.

Thisara is an ouside chance for the 2nd test over Pradeep

Not sure about Mendis coming in. He is yet to prove himself as an ODI much less a test possibility just yet. Besides Herath and Randiv are forming a very good combination the more they play. See no reason to break that up at the moment purely for variation.

ps- Mathews bowling is probably not a good idea considering how injury prone he is. Certainly not as an opening bowler.

CGI's picture
Member since:
25 May 2012
Last activity:
10 weeks 1 day

My opinion
* - Pakistani batsmen are not quite up to the standards and most of them don't have proper technique, foot movements, etc. Apart from Misbah and Younis Khan all the other batsmen are tentative. Their strength is the bowling. So any opposition with good bowling attack can upset Pakistan's batting line up.

* - Randiv looks good, but he has lot to improve. I feel now he is a average bowler and will improve if he gets his position continuously. He should be given confidence and matches to improve.

* - Nuwan Pradeep, I think its a mistake that he has been included in to the side. Because he is not consistent with his line, he can't seam or swing the ball, he don't have enough variations. There are lot more better bowlers. Suranga Lakmal would have been a better choice, he can swing/seam the ball, 130+ Kph speed. Good line and length. Even Thisara Perera can do a better job. I think, ODI experience will give something to Pradeep. Test is not suitable for him.

* - Paranavithana, Dilshan's opening partner is quite volatile. Still we don't have proper partner. Nobody does the job as expected. So its time to find a young gem. Now Para is 30+ in age. So chance to Thirimanne(23) is what I like. I saw a new guy in recent domestic season, Ashen Silva(22) from Lankan CC. His domestic record is quite outstanding. So chance to him might be a good investment.

* - I think if the selectors don't include Suranga Lakmal for the second test, then Thisara Perera should be picked as the replacement for Nuwan Pradeep. Thisara's recent form should be acknowledged. It'll give confidence and experience to this young gem.

* - Sanga, simply outstanding in the first inning, 199 not out without a single chance, quite unbelievable. But Dilshan's fire crackers helped him a lot.

* - Dilly, as usual he has done the job. Perfect team player.

* - Mahela, want more consistancy from the captain. Middle order needs Mahela's support.

* - Samaraweera, we expect his gun fire in the SSC. He was quite uncomfortable, but expect something different in his home ground.

* Hera & Kula - Brilliant. bowlers we can depend. Especially Hera, attacking from the first ball, no loosners. always build the pressure.

p.s- Pakistanis will come back hard with Misbah. It won't be easy at SSC as Galle. So middle order has to be prepared for their attack. Mahela, Samarewwera, Mathews, these three have to take responsibility and play better than Galle. Good luck SLC....!!!

Post new comment

Note
All anonymous comments are moderated.
  • Avoid abusive remarks and personal attacks.
  • Avoid posting unrelated links.
  • Avoid vulgar or obscene language.
Already a member? Log-in now. Not a member? Sign up for a new account.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
Enter each letter you see in the box below. It helps us prevent automated submissions from spammers.